Ordering from EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN
9 Main Street, Sussex, NJ
9 Main Street, Sussex, NJ
Appetizers
Quesadillas
$12.75
·Chicken aged cheddar jack, tomatoes, scallions, sour cream, salsa
Fresh Clams
$13.50
·Ipa steamed littlenecks in thyme, lemon butter, shaved garlic
Bangin' Shrimp
$14.75
·A tavern made classic, jumbo shrimp - battered and fried, sweet and spicy sauce
Seasonal Crab Cakes
$14.50
·Lump crab meat, roasted corn, pepper, red onion, seasoned, side seasonal salsa or tavern tartar
Golden Onion Petals
$8.50
·Side of chipotle aioli
Fried Pickles
$8.75
·Pickles - seasoned, breaded, fried, chipotle sauce
Loaded Tots
$11.50
·Piled high tots, bacon, brown gravy, cheddar, scallions
The Giant Pretzel
$12.00
·Soft pretzel, whiskey honey mustard, beer cheese dip
Pretzel Bites
$9.75
·Soft mini, beer cheese dip
Bacon Bombs!
$12.50
·Dough filled mozzarella and cheddar balls wrapped in bacon tossed tomato salad and balsamic glaze
Fried Pieroggis
$9.00
·Staple comfort food. 4 flour dumplings filled with potato, cheese, and onions, smothered with caramelized onions butter sauce and sour cream
Nacho Supreme
$10.75
·Tavern-made chips, beef chili, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomato, black olives, sour cream, scallions, mild salsa
Deviled Eggs
$6.00
·Classic deviled eggs tavern made with care and piled high
Tavern Knots
$9.50
·Flash Fried, Marinara Dipping sauce.
Fire Roasted Shishito Peppers
$11.75
·Oven Grilled Japanese Pepper, Tossed in Tajin Seasoning, Cotija Cheese, Served with Herb Yogurt Dip.
E.A.T. Wings
Bone-in or Boneless. Sauces is made in house!
Cups, Crocks, & Bowls
French Onion Soup
$7.00
·Caramelized onions, beef, touch of sherry, toasted bread, extra heavy swiss cheese melt
Beef Chili
$7.00
·USDA angus beef, tomato, staple vegetables, cheddar, dark chili seasoning, red kidney beans
Smokey Mac & Cheese
$8.00
·Creamy Béchamel plus a 4 Cheese blend Crispy Parmesan Bread Crumb Topping.
Salads
Dressings choices: oil & vinegar, Italian, blue cheese, ranch, honey dijon, balsamic vinaigrette, thousand island, Parmesan peppercorn
Goat Cheese Salad
$14.00
·Baby spinach, red onion, fresh berries, raspberry vinaigrette, pistachio crusted goat cheese balls
The Grilled Caesars Salad
$9.00
·Romaine, creamy caesar dressing
California Cobb Salad
$14.00
·Grilled chicken, applewood bacon, avocado, tomato, hard-cooked eggs, spring mix
House Salad
$5.00
·Spring mix, tomato, onion, shredded carrots, cucumbers, black olives
The B.A.L.T.
$14.00
·Chopped Salad- Bacon, Avocado, Lettuce, Tomato, Chopped Onion, Hard Boiled Egg, Balsamic Vinaigrette
Wraps
Wraps come with fries or chips, coleslaw, pickle
Applewood Chicken Wrap
$11.00
·Grilled chicken, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, Monterey jack and cheddar
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$11.00
·Breaded chicken breasts smothered in buffalo sauce topped lettuce, tomato & mozzarella cheese
Grilled Caesar Wrap
$9.00
·Romaine, creamy caesar dressing, Parmesan
Cajun Shrimp
$16.00
·Jumbo Shrimp, Seasoned, Drizzled with house BBQ, Shredded Lettuce, Diced Tomatoes, Cheddar-Jack Blend, Fresh Onion, Chipotle Ranch Dressing.
Paninis
Paninis come with fries or chips, coleslaw, pickle
Chicken Mango & Pepper Jack Panini
$11.00
·Grilled chicken, mango salsa, tomato, pepper-jack cheese, grilled flat bread
Black Forest Ham, Apple & Brie Panini
$11.00
·Black forest ham, fire roasted fuji apples, mango aioli, melted brie cheese
The B.R.B.
$13.00
·Bacon, Ranch Dressing, Thin Sliced Beef, Sliced Tomato, Fresh Iceberg Lettuce
Sandwiches
Sandwiches come with fries or chips, coleslaw, pickle
Tavern Cheesesteak Sandwich
$13.50
·Hand-cut angus, American cheese, sauteed mushrooms, onions, peppers, hoagie roll
Prime Rib Sandwich
$15.50
·House rib-eye, mushrooms, caramelized onion, mozzarella, garlic baguette
Reuben Sandwich
$14.75
·Open-faced, melted swiss, russian dressing, rye
B.L.T.A. Sandwich
$12.00
·Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mayo, on Toasted Wheat-berry Bread
High Point Pulled Pork Sandwich
$13.75
·Tavern made & piled high, pulled pork, North Jersey BBQ Sauce, onion petals, coleslaw. pickle chips, jersey deli mustard
Sweet & Spicy Chicken Sandwich
$14.75
·Fried jumbo chicken breast, jalapeno relish, habanero mayo, lettuce, tomato, avocado, crispy onions, spicy butter sauce
Tavern Dip
$17.00
·Sliced Brisket, Swiss Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Horseradish Cream Sauce, Smoked Au Jus, Texas Toast.
Tavern King Fish
$13.75
·Crisp, Fried White Fish, Dill Pickle, Fresh Tomato, Shredded Lettuce, Tavern Made Tartar on Brioche
Tuscan Chicken Caprese
$15.00
·Grilled Chicken Breast, Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Spinach, Sliced Tomato, Balsamic Reduction
Grilled Cheese
Grilled cheeses come with fries or chips, coleslaw, pickle
Signature Tavern Burgers
All signature burgers can be made with a grilled chicken breast
Moonshine BBQ Burger
$14.50
·Certified angus beef, applewood bacon, cheddar, moonshine BBQ sauce, sauteed onions, brioche roll
Irish Burger
$16.50
·Chuck Burger, corned beef, coleslaw, Irish cheddar cheese
Livin' Large Burger
$16.50
·EAT signature patty topped with pulled short rib, sharp cheddar special sauce, and fried egg, brioche roll
Shrooms and Swiss Burger
$13.50
·Mushrooms and swiss, sauteed onions, and 1000 island au ju sauce on an EAT signature patty
Spice is Nice Burger
$13.50
·Certified angus, roasted jalapeno, spicy chipotle bbq, sweet relish pepper jack cheese
Bigger "On" Texas Burger
$19.50
·Double American cheese burgers, crispy onions, on garlic bread Texas toast, side of sriracha house ranch dressing!
The Jersey Burger
$14.50
·Taylor ham, egg, and cheese on a burger roll
Bat Out of Hell Burger
$13.00
·So simple, so delicious. Sliced meatloaf, brown gravy, & mashed potatoes on toasted bread served with onion rings
Simply Salmon Burger
$16.00
·Tavern-made, avocado, lettuce, vine ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, signature sauce, pita
Portabella Heaven Burger
$14.00
·Portabella mushroom topped with melted swiss, onion, tomato, spinach, avocado, roasted red pepper spread
Personal Pies
Cheese Steak - Personal Pie
$15.00
·Tavern-sliced steak, peppers, onion, cheese
Pulled Pork - Personal Pie
$15.00
·Pulled pork, cheddar Monterrey cheese, peach bourbon BBQ sauce
Buffalo Chicken - Personal Pie
$15.00
·Breaded chicken, mozzarella, bleu cheese, hot sauce
Cheese - Personal Pie
$10.00
·Hand-made, savory sauce, mozzarella blend
Margherita - Personal Pie
$13.00
·Savory tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil
Signature Calzones
The Tavern Calzone
$12.00
·(Deep Fried or Baked) Custom blend of seasoned Ricotta and Mozzarella wrapped in our house made dough served with Marinara sauce.
Margherita - Calzone
$15.00
·Savory tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil
Buffalo Chicken - Calzone
$17.00
·Breaded chicken, mozzarella, bleu cheese, hot sauce
Pulled Pork - Calzone
$17.00
·Cheese Steak - Calzone
$17.00
·Tavern-sliced steak, peppers, onion, cheese
Beef Entrees
All entrees served with vegetables du jour. Starch choice: potato, pasta, or rice (where applicable)
Poultry Entrees
All entrees served with vegetables du jour
Eat Homestyle Entrees
All entrees served with vegetables du jour
Shepard's Pie
$19.75
·Ground lamb, burgundy reduction sauce, chopped vegetables topped with Yukon gold potato mash
Veggie Stuffed Peppers
$16.75
·Large bell peppers stuffed with wild rice, mushrooms, fresh seasonal vegetables and beans, and cilantro lime sauce
Smoked Meat Loaf
$22.75
·Bacon Wrapped, Smoked on Site, Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Drizzled Demi Sauce, Crispy Onions. Served over Crispy Bread
Pasta Entrees
All entrees served with vegetables du jour, starch choice: potato, pasta, or rice (where applicable)
Sides
Garlic Spinach
$5.00
·Pasta
$7.00
·Butter, tomato, aglio olio
EAT Corn Bread
$6.00
·Tavern Baked, Bacon, Shallot, Cheddar
Baked Beans
$6.00
·Tavern Made & Filled with Smoke Trimmings
Brussel Sprouts
$6.00
·Crispy, Fresh, Garlic Butter Herb
Seasonal Vegetable
$6.00
·In-Season Vegetables Prepared In house
Creamed Spinach
$5.00
·Important information regarding calories
Adults and youth (ages 13 and older) need an average of 2,000 calories a day. Children (ages 4 to 12) need an average of 1,500 calories a day. Individual needs may vary. For additional nutrition information, contact our restaurant.