Best American restaurant in Sussex

Early American Tavern – Your Rustic Haven for American Goodness!

Order Online

Visit one of the best restaurants in Sussex

EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN has truly stood out among the rest and has been named one of the best restaurants in Sussex!

Order here

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Fresh Clams

Ipa steamed littlenecks in thyme, lemon butter, shaved garlic

Add Item

Bangin' Shrimp

A tavern made classic, jumbo shrimp - battered and fried, sweet and spicy sauce

Add Item

Seasonal Crab Cakes

Lump crab meat, roasted corn, pepper, red onion, seasoned, side seasonal salsa or tavern tartar

Add Item

Golden Onion Petals

Side of chipotle aioli

Add Item

Quesadillas

Chicken aged cheddar jack, tomatoes, scallions, sour cream, salsa

Add Item

Experience the Flavor of Home

Located at 9 Main Street, Sussex, New Jersey 07461, Early American Tavern invites you to experience the heart and soul of American comfort food. Our ambiance is as warm as a crackling fireplace on a chilly day, providing the perfect backdrop for a relaxed dining experience. From hearty burgers to crispy fried chicken, each dish is a nod to the classics that define American comfort cuisine. At Early American Tavern, we keep it simple and delicious – just like Mom used to make.

Events with a Dash of American Flavor

Planning a celebration? Let Early American Tavern cater to your cravings! Our catering service brings the flavor of America to your gatherings, ensuring your guests enjoy every bite of classic American goodness. From birthdays to office parties, we make your event special with a touch of rustic charm.

Reserve Your Spot

For those moments when you want to savor the rustic ambiance and enjoy a sit-down meal, we offer reservations. Your seat is ready and waiting at Early American Tavern, promising a cozy atmosphere and a menu that hits all the right notes.

Easy as Pie – Ordering Made Simple

In today's hustle and bustle, we know you're looking for a hassle-free dining experience. That's why we've made ordering from Early American Tavern a breeze. Whether you prefer the convenience of delivery to your doorstep, a quick curbside pickup, or taking the flavors of Early American Tavern home with our takeout service – we've got you covered.

Dive into the Experience

Ready to embark on your own American adventure? Swing by our location at 9 Main Street, Sussex, New Jersey 07461, or simply click to order online. Early American Tavern is here to make your dining experience easy, delicious, and filled with all-American charm. We can't wait to welcome you! 🍔🍟🚗 #EarlyAmericanEats

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

We stopped in for a meal with friends. The food was amazing, I had the prime rib and it did not disappoint at all. Cooked beautifully, and the creamed spinach was second to none. The wait staff was super friendly and on point with everything. Whenever the next time we are in Sussex again, we will definitely be stopping here again!!!

Matthew B.

I’ve passed this place probably 100 times in my life and never ate there. Today my husband and I finally did and it was great! I loved the cozy atmosphere and wish we lived closer because I’m sure we’d be regulars. It does however give us an excuse to go out for a ride. Will be bringing my folks back for sure. Very good!

Tracy R.

Fun night out. Large tables so tables of 6 are easy to seat. The service and food were good. Always a festive atmosphere. The sweet potato fries are super yum and I really enjoyed the prime rib sandwich. Dietary restrictions: Gf buns and bread available